Cover Image
close this bookDisaster Management Ethics (Department of Humanitarian Affairs/United Nations Disaster Relief Office - United Nations Development Programme , 1997, 70 p.)
close this folderTOPIC 2 Providing humanitarian assistance to displaced populations and refugees
View the document(introduction...)
View the documentThe nature of the working environment in contemporary emergencies
View the documentEthical dilemmas and humanitarian relief
View the documentStrategies for the negotiation of rights
View the documentIdentifying and understanding the limits to available policy instruments
View the documentLabeling and counting beneficiaries
View the documentProviding relief versus securing rights: ethical assistance strategies
View the documentDilemmas in participation
View the documentDisplaced people, refugees and local hosts
View the documentAddressing the needs of women
View the documentObligations to staff
View the documentConclusion
View the documentResponse by Phil Anderson
View the documentResponse by Jacques Cuenod
View the documentResponse by Arthur E. Dewey

Displaced people, refugees and local hosts

Relief systems somewhat artificially label the displaced or refugee population as distinct from the local hosts and can create tensions where people are part of common social networks, and have similar needs. In cases where hosts consider themselves to be very different from the displaced, a negative reaction to targeted assistance is likely. This can undermine host political will to provide asylum, and can damage livelihood because access to host resources (rather than relief items) is usually the greatest determinant of refugee well-being. It is ironic that local hosts who provide the key assistance in the early stages of any emergency can become alienated by subsequent relief efforts, and even hostile to the refugees.

Policy approaches that maintain local host understanding of, and commitment to, the refugees’ needs are therefore advised - alongside programs with mutual benefit to both hosts and refugees. Programs where the two groups benefit alongside one another (e.g., by attending the same schools or hospitals), foster a sense of integration. Where it is unavoidable that refugees be assisted separately from hosts, it is appropriate to improve services for the surrounding host populations. When refugee repatriation occurs, in the immediate post-departure period, new initiatives are particularly needed that address the residual economic and ecological impact in host countries.