Cover Image
close this bookDisaster Management Ethics - Trainer's Guide - 1st Edition (Disaster Management Training Programme, 104 p.)
close this folderTOPIC 5: Disaster declaration and response
View the document(introduction...)
View the document54. Introduction
View the document55. Ethical issues
View the document56. Ethical Issue #1
View the document57. Ethical Issue #2
View the document58. Ethical Issue #3
View the document59. Ethical Issue #4
View the document60. Ethical Issue #5
View the document61. Ethical Issue #6
View the document62. Ethical Issue #7
View the document63. Deliberating ethical issues
View the document64. Factors influencing ethical deliberations
View the document65. Summary

62. Ethical Issue #7


Figure

Justice and national policy: whose values count?

Present the dilemma and ask participants to provide examples from their experience when they were involved in negotiating conflicting value differences between groups. What factors influenced the decision that was made? Note examples and factors on a flip chart.

If participants are unable to identify a clear example you might raise examples from Bosnia, El Salvador, Guatemala, Iraq, Sudan and other places where government policies have violated the human and civil rights of its citizens. The international community has become involved in disaster situations created by such policies, providing humanitarian assistance to displaced persons and refugees who have been dislocated.