Integrating criteria and indicators of sustainable forest management in the national forest programmes. (1997): ANNEX 5: PROPOSITIONS FOR THE USE OF CRITERIA AND INDICATORS

Integrating criteria and indicators of sustainable forest management in the national forest programmes. (1997)

		(introduction...)
		I. NATIONAL FOREST PROGRAMMES AND CRITERIA & INDICATORS OF SUSTAINABLE FOREST MANAGEMENT
		II. A PRELIMINARY STUDY
		III. A COMPARATIVE APPROACH
		IV. A PROCEDURE TO BE CONDUCTED
		V. THE ROLE OF FOREST RESOURCES ASSESSMENT SYSTEMS
		ANNEX 1: LIST OF INDICATORS
		ANNEX 2: THE INDICATORS RECOGNISED IN THE SECTOR-BASED NFP STUDIES
		ANNEX 3: INDICATORS RECOGNISED IN THE NFPS OF THE COUNTRIES STUDIED
		ANNEX 4: INDICATORS DEFINED FOLLOWING THE NFP THEMES
		ANNEX 5: PROPOSITIONS FOR THE USE OF CRITERIA AND INDICATORS
		ANNEX 6: POSSIBLE INDICATORS FOR SECTOR-BASED STUDIES OF THE NFP PROCESS
		ANNEX 7: THE INDICATORS OF GFRA 2000 AND THEIR ROLE IN THE NFP PROCESS

ANNEX 5: PROPOSITIONS FOR THE USE OF CRITERIA AND INDICATORS

FOREST MANAGEMENT

	Formulation Indicators		Implementation Indicators	Monitoring Indicators	Evaluation Indicators
	Situation	Alert
Initial set a 0
			- Valorization of local expertise, knowledge and local technologies - Transfer and adaptation of appropriate technologies
Set a 1
	- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area/2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3		- Research and extension capacity	-Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area /2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3
Results of: Initial set a 0 + Set a1: analysis of Forest Inventory
Supplementary set a 2
		- Forest area converted to other uses/9 - Forest area and other wooded land burnt annually/38			- Forest area converted to other uses /2 - % of managed forest according to a management plan or management guidelines/55
Results of: Initial set a 0 + Set al + Supplementary set a 2: analysis of Forest Management
Organization of set of Indicators for Forest Management
Set a 0 + Set a 1: Forest Inventory + Set a 2: Forest Management

ECOSYSTEMS CONSERVATION

	Formulation	Indicators	Implementation Indicators	Monitoring Indicators	Evaluation Indicators
	Situation	Alert
Initial set b 0
	- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area/2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3 - Forest plantation area per species category/4 - Average standing volume, possibly by vegetation zones or site classes/15 - Area of forest land available for wood production/57	- Forest area converted to other uses /9 - Number of endangered forests, and change process/33	- Valorization of local expertise, knowledge and local technologies - Transfer and adaptation of appropriate technologies - Research and extension capacity	- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area /2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3 - Forest plantations Area per species category/4 - Average standing volume, possibly by vegetation zones or site classes/15 - Area of forest land available for wood production/57	- % of managed forest according to a management plan or management guidelines/55
Set b1
				- Forest area and % of area managed primarily for soil protection/66 - Forest area and % of area managed primarily for water protection/67	- Forest area and % of area managed primarily for soil protection/66 - Forest area and % of area managed primarily for water protection/67
Results of: Initial set b 0 + Set b1: analysis of Environment, Soil and Water Conservation
Set b1-1
	- Forest land area with a conserahle soil erosion/68	- Number of endangered forests, and change process/33
Results of: Initial set b 0 + Set b 1 + Set b 1 -1: analysis of Watershed Management
Set b2
	- Area of natural forest or forest assimilated as such, and change process/23 - Number of forest species/32 - Area managed with primary objective leisure and tourism/75		- Management of landscape/77	- Area of natural forest or forest assimilated as such, and change process/23 - Number of forest species/32 - Area managed with primary objective leisure and tourism/75
Results of: Initial set b0 + Set b2: analysis of Nature Conservation System, National Parks and Protected Area
Set b2-1
	- Area of strictly protected forest reserves, and forests that are protected by a special management regime and change process/26			- Area of strictly protected forest reserves, and forests that are protected by a special management regime and change process/26	- Production of non-wood forest products/80
Results of Initial set b0+ Set b2 + Set b2-1- analysis of Wildlife Management and Protected Areas
Set b2-1-1
	- Share of forest sector in GNP/GDP				- Share of forest sector in GNP/GDP
Results of: Initial set b 0 + Set b2 + Set b2-1 + Set b2-1-1: analysis of Wildlife Resources
Results of the whole set: analysis of Ecosystems Conservation

FOREST GENETIC and SEEDS analysed by the following set:

Formulation Indicators		Implementation Indicators	Monitoring Indicators	Evaluation Indicators
Situation	Alert
- Area of forest and vegetation types/3 - Area of strictly protected forest reserves, and forests that are protected by a special management regime and change process/26 - Number of forest species/32 - Forest plantations area per species category/4		- Valorization of local expertise, knowledge and local technologies - Transfer and adaptation of appropriate technologies - Research and extension capacity	- Area of strictly protected forest reserves, and forests that are protected by a special management regime and change process/26 - Forest plantations area per species category/4	- Proportion of plantations managed for the conservation and the use of forest genetic resources/29

FUELWOOD SECTOR analysed by the following set:

Formulation Indicators		Implementation Indicators	Monitoring Indicators	Evaluation Indicators
Situation	Alert
- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area /2 - Forest plantationa area per species category/4 - Biomass according to forest types/11 - Total standing volume/14 - Average standing volume possibly by vegetation zones or site classes/15 - Average consumption of fuelwood per caput and per year/63 - Value from biomass energy	- Forest area converted to other uses/9	-Valorization of local expertise, knowledge and local technologies - Transfer and adaptation of appropriate technologies - Research and extension capacity	- Forest plantationa area per species category/4 - Forest area converted to other uses/9 - Biomass according to forest types/11 - Area of forest land available for wood production/57 - Volume of estimated sustainable forest production compared to total production/61 - Average consumption of fuelwood per caput and per year/63 - Benefits accruing to local communities - Value from biomass energy- Forest sector trade balance	- % of managed forest according to a management plan or management guidelines/55

FORESTRY LAND USE

	Formulation Indicators		Implementation Indicators		Monitoring Indicators	Evaluation Indicators
	Situation	Alert
Initial set c 0
	- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area/2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3 - Forest plantations area per species categories/4	- Forest area converted to other uses/9 - Forest area and other wooded land burnt annually/38 - Forest land area with a considerable soil erosion/68	- Valorization of local expertise, knowledge and local technologies - Transfer and adaptation of appropriate technologies - Research and extension capacity		- Forest area/1 - Other wooded land area/2 - Area of forest and vegetation types/3 - Forest plantations area per species category/4 - Forest area converted to other uses /9	- % of managed forest according to a management plan or management guidelines/55
Set c1
	- Total standing volume/14 - Average standing volume possibly by vegetation zones or site classes/15 - Value of wood products - Value of non-wood forest products - Average consumption of fuelwood per caput and per year/63				- Total standing volume/14 - Average standing volume possibly by vegetation zones or site classes/15 - Value of wood products - Value of non-wood forest products - Average consumption of fuelwood per caput and per year/63
Results of: Initial set c 0 + Set c1: analysis of Management of Forest Resources and Village Lands
Set c2
	- Average consumption of fuelwood per caput and per year/63 - Benefits accruing to local communities	- Forest land area with compacted soils and/or whose physical properties have been altered/70			- Volume of wood production/79 - Production of non-wood forest products/80 - Benefits accruing to local communities
Results of: Initial set c 0 + Set c2: analysis of Forestry and Rural Development
Set c3
		- Volume of wood production/79 - Production of non-wood forest products/80			- Volume of wood production/79 - Production of non-wood forest products/80
Results of: Initial set c0 + Set c3: analysis of Agro-Forestry
	- Area of natural forest or forest assimilated as such, and change process/23			- Forest area by ownership type/6 - Area of natural forest or forest assimilated as such, and change process/23 - Forest area and % of area, managed primarily for soil protection/66 - Forest area and % of area, managed primarily for water protection/67 - Maintenance of cultural, social and spiritual values/76 - Benefits accruing to local communities
Results of the wholes set: analysis of Forestry Land Us