Cover Image
close this bookCase Studies of Neem Processing Projects Assisted by GTZ in Kenya, Dominican Republic, Thailand and Nicaragua (GTZ, 2000, 152 p.)
close this folder4. Case studies of small-scale semi-industrial neem processing in Kenya, Thailand, the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua
close this folder4.3. Small-scale industrial manufacturing of neem-based pesticides in the Dominican Republic
close this folder4.3.5 Market potential for neem pesticides in the Dominican Republic
View the document4.3.5.1 Marketing to date
View the document4.3.5.2 Market potential of neem pesticides
View the document4.3.5.3 Analysis of the economic production with and without the use of neem pesticides
View the document4.3.5.4 Market growth potential and substitution possibilities

4.3.5.1 Marketing to date

In the Dominican Republic it is common practice to apply synthetic insecticides. All pesticides are imported since no pesticides are manufactured in the country, except for neem pesticides.

The Secretaria de Estado de Agriculura (SEA), Departemento de Sanidad Vegetal Division de Registro de Plaguicidas is in charge of supervising the import of insecticides.

In 1998 957,729 l/kg of insecticides of US$ 6,810,527.51 value were imported to Dom Republic

In principle all agricultural inputs imported to the Dominican Republic are free of tax, to enhance agricultural production. This also applies to pesticides. However, traders usually have 80 - 100% mark-up on the wholesale price and thus increase the price of agricultural inputs considerably.

IPM systems have been introduced to overcome the problems caused by indiscriminate use of broad spectrum pesticides, but are not available for all crops and are not applied countrywide.

The obvious main pest the farmers encounter is the whitefly Bemisia tabaci which is resistant to all broad-spectrum insecticides. This problem has led to a special governmental directive, Resolution 37/99 Manejo on "Control y Prevencion de la Mosca Blanca", which regulates the cultivation areas and times for tomatoes.

FAMA's neem-based pesticides are most effective against the following groups of pests:

· larvae of Lepidoptera
· aphids
· whitefly (B. tabaci)

Their neem-based pesticides compete with the pesticides shown below:

Table 48: Price, target pests and crops of products competing with neem pesticides in the Dominican Republic

Name of the product

Price of the product US$/kg

Pest

Crop

M.T.D. 600

5.00

Lepidoptera larvae

Cucurbitacea




Solanacea




Leguminosae

Decis

17.65

Lepidoptera larvae

Cucurbitacea




Solanacea




Leguminosae

Tamaron

10.00

Lepidoptera larvae

Cucurbitacea




Solanacea




Leguminosae

Lannate

22.00

Lepidoptera larvae

Cucurbitacea




Solanacea




Leguminosa

Monitor

10.00

Lepidoptera larvae

Cucurbitacea




Solanacea




Leguminosae

Diazinon

12.94

Lepidoptera and aphids

Solanacea




Albemoschus




Esculantum

Thiodan

11.88

Whitefly (B. tabaci)

Solanacea

Eviset

20.38

Whitefly (B. tabaci)

Cucurbitacea




Leguminosae

Danitol

32.81

Whitefly (B. tabaci)

Cucurbitacea




Leguminosae

Pegasus

75.25

Whitefly (B. tabaci)

Solanacea




Cucurbitacea

Thionex

11.00

Whitefly (B. tabaci)

Solanaceas




Cucurbitacea

Ekatin

9.15

Whitefly and Lepidoptera

Leguminosae




Cucurbitacea

Javelin

27.94

Lepidoptera and whitefly

Many

Dipel

18

Lepidoptera and whitefly

Many

The above list indicates that neem products are some of the most expensive pesticides. An exception is the product "Pegasus" which is a selective pesticide against whiteflies and which is more expensive than neem.

Formulated neem oil is cheaper than ground neem seeds and easier to apply. However, these types of pesticides cannot be compared directly because to a certain extent they affecting different pest species.

While synthetic insecticides can be applied on all sorts of crops, neem products are currently only used in high-priced niche markets such as vegetables, fruit and flowers. Neem is not applied on staple crops such as corn and legumes. It is only competitive within some IPM concepts and where no synthetic insecticides are allowed (organic farming).

Farmers applying neem in the Dominican Republic are cropping according to IPM or organic farming principles, often assisted by projects.

To date the small-scale industrial production of neem products in the Dominican Republic is producing a considerable amount for export.

Trading chain

In the Dominican Republic pesticides, especially insecticides are distributed from importers to retailers. The addresses of retailers have to be registered in a special data base. Neem products are usually not sold via the normal agricultural supply trading system. One exception is the wholesaler LIGA.

The present market share of neem products can only be estimated: in 1998 FAMA produced 4 200 tonnes of formulated neem oil, of which 56% has been exported and 44% sold on the national market. Additionally most of the ground neem seeds and cake has been exported. Given that the total value of imported insecticides was 6.5 million dollars, neem pesticides have a market share of about 0.25%.