Cover Image
close this bookEnvironmental Handbook Volume II: Agriculture, Mining/Energy, Trade/Industry (GTZ, 1995, 736 p.)
close this folderTrade and industry
close this folder58. Pulp and paper
View the document1. Scope
View the document2. Environmental impacts and protective measures
View the document3. Notes on the analysis and evaluation of environmental impacts
View the document4. Interaction with other sectors
View the document5. Summary assessment of environmental relevance
View the document6. References
View the documentAppendix A: Tables
View the documentAppendix B: Glossary

Appendix A: Tables

Table 1. 2. Basic Data Relating to Pulp












Abbrev.

Type

Yield as a % of raw material


Spec. energy consumption (kWh/t pulp)


Rel. chemical use in relation to raw material


Rel. pollutant output after process untreated,


Rel. environmental impact after treatment (a)




Wood

Annual plants

Wood

Annual plants

Wood

Annual plants

Wood

Annual plants

Wood

Annual plants

GW

"mechanical" stock (wood pulp)

99-100

--

1600-2000

--

very low

--

low

--

low

--

TMP

Thermo-mech. pulp

97-98

--

1800-2400

--

very low

--

low

--

low

--

CTMP

Chem. thermo- mech. pulp

91-97

--

low

--

medium

--

low

--

CMP

Chem. mech. pulp

82-96

(70-80)

min. 930

min. 600

medium

(medium)

medium

medium

low

low

SCP

Semi- chemical pulp

62-82

50-60

800-900

500-600

high

medium

high

high

low

low/very high (c)

CP

Chemical pulp

40-60

30-40

very high

high

very high

very high

low/medium (b)

low/very high (c)

AP

Waste paper stock

80-95


200-400


low

low/medium


low


(a): state-of-the-art emission treatment
(b): noxiousness dependent on the type of bleaching chemicals: with or without chlorine
(c): dependent on the technical or economic feasibility of recovery or destruction of spent pulping chemicals

Table 2.2.1A Aqueous Emissions Pulp and Paper Mills Page 1





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Open water circuits

Large quantity of wastewater

Large treatment plant, high energy and chemical consumption

Closing of internal circuits

To approx. 80%

Undissolved substances from various sources/ careless process control

Organic fibre components and inorganic components (dirt), filler remains

Turbidity, color, oxygen consumption, smell

Division of process water flows, closing of circuits in mill, improved filtration

Varies depending on production type

Dissolved substances from pulp production and recovery

Ligno-sulphonates, other lignin decomposition products, crude tall oil etc., organic sulphur compounds, Na salts

Marked brown coloration, oxygen consumption (in part difficultly degradable), odour nuisance

Optimisation of process stages, leak prevention, recycling of leaked liquid

Up to 90%

Pulp bleaching

Decomposition products of lignin and hemicellulose, chlorinated organic compounds, Na and Cl salts

Oxygen consumption (in part difficultly degradable), discoloration, toxicity

Recycling of filtrates in plant, leak prevention, conversion to chlorine-free/ low-chlorine bleaching

Chlorinated compounds up to 100%, others only slightly

Condensates

Organic compounds (methanol, ethanol, uncondensed gases)

High oxygen consumption, color, odour nuisance

Liquor stripping in/before condensation, combustion or separate processing of stripper gases

Up to over 90%

Table 2.2.1A Aqueous Emissions Pulp and Paper Mills Page 2





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Chemicals from waste paper pro-cessing

Printing ink components (in part containing heavy metals), dyes, processing chemicals, complex salts

Turbidity, oxygen consumption, toxicity (with heavy metals)

Closed circuit management (restricted), toxicity can be reduced indirectly by using printing inks without heavy metal components

Oxygen consumption low, toxicity high

Paper manufacture

Remains of chemical additives (dyes, brighteners, anti-foaming agents, retention and cleaning agents, fillers)

Turbidity, oxygen consumption (toxicity, if additive toxic)

As for waste paper

As for waste paper

Coating plant

Coating materials (latex, clay, emulsifiers, starch etc.)

Turbidity, oxygen consumption

Careful process management to prevent losses

--

Wastewater from secondary installations

Chemicals from water softening/ demineralisation, clarification salts etc.

Salt content

--

--

Table 2.2.1A Aqueous Emissions Pulp and Paper Mills Page 3





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Wastewater treatment plant

A) In the wastewater: oxygen-consuming substances (lignin and cellulose decomposition), dyes B) In treated sludge: organic and inorganic solids (incl. toxic components), products of bio-degradation

Turbidity, discoloration, oxygen consumption --

Mechanical (sedimentation, filtration, flotation), biological (aerobic, anaerobic) and possibly chemical (precipitation, adsorption with active carbon etc.) wastewater treatment Sludge incineration (possibly with flue gas scrubbing)

Colour: 95%, oxygen: up to around 60%, (pulp) and up to 95% (paper), colouring: up to 100% Over 90%

Table 2.2.1 B Examples of Quantitative Emission Values Aqueous emissions, pulp production, untreated

Table 2.2.1 B Examples of Quantitative Emission Values







Aqueous emissions, pulp production, untreated







Wastewater quantity m³/t

BOD kg/t

COD kg/t

ss kg/t

AOx kg/t

TOX (TEF)

Wood pulp TMP CTMP SC C sulphate C sulphite

1) 2) 20 8 50 50 225 450

1) 2) 10-30 15-28 315) 10-20 40-605) 250-500* 60-200* *

1) 2) 3xBOD 3xBOD

1) 2)

3) 4) 1-2 5 0-0.2 5

Aqueous emissions, paper production, untreated







Graphic papers Newsprint MF writing and printing papers Industrial papers Common wrapping papers

25 80 70 180 0 50

1-2 0 3

0 - 3

10 40 30 80 0 10-30

--

6)

*: no chemical recovery
* *: with chemical recovery
1) with water circuits largely closed in the mill
2) with water circuits largely open
3) with chlorinated bleaches largely avoided
4) with chlorinated bleach
5) value range SSVL (Sweden)
6) printing inks containing heavy metals can yield toxic sludges
TEF Toxicity Emission Factor

Table 2.2.2 A Emissions into the Air Pulp and Paper Mills

Table 2.2.2 A Emissions into the Air Pulp and Paper Mills Page 1





Sources/causes typical in the sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state-of-the-art) in the mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Raw material crushing and cleaning (chopping of wood, straw etc.)

Organic dust

Fire risk constituting health hazard

Extracting of air and cleaning in cyclones (and/or filtering, recycling, burning or dumping of dust)

up to 100%

Waste gases from digesters, steaming out of equipment and vessels

Steam, turpentine, other HC compounds, SO2

Fire risk, odour nuisance, health hazard, acid rain

Condense steam and turpentine, recycle turpentine, burn residue, recycle SO2 in the process, scrub residual gases

99 +

TRS

Odour nuisance

Collect and burn TRS (cannot be condensed)

99 +

Fumes of spent liquor condensation plant

Steam, terpenses, methanol, TRS

Odour nuisance

Collect and burn gases

95 +

Steam

--

--

--

SO2

Acid rain

Absorption in alkaline gas scrubbers, recycling in process

99 +

NO2

Ozone formation

In development: noncatalytic conversion

0

TRS

Odour nuisance process

State-of-the-art process

99 +

Recovery boiler (waste gases)

CO

Health hazard

Minimise by process

0

CO2

Greenhouse effect

Unavoidable, does not pollute global balance

0

Dust

Health hazard

Electro-filters, recycling in process

99 +

Table 2.2.2 A Emissions into the Air Pulp and Paper Mills Page 2





Sources/causes typical in the sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state-of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Steam

--

--

--

SO2

Acid rain

Use of S-free fuel oil or natural gas; in development: wood and bark gas

95 +

CO

Health hazard

Minimise by process management

0

Lime kiln (waste gases)

NOx

Ozone formation

Reduction not yet state-of-the-art (cf. cement sector)

0

TRS

Odour nuisance

Minimisation possible by good process management

99 +

Dust

Health hazard

Electric filters and recycling in process

99 +

Steam

--

--

--

Steam boiler fired by bark or waste wood

CO2 and CO

Greenhouse effect, health hazard

Unavoidable, but does not affect the global balance, minimisation by process management

(waste gases)

Hydrocarbons

Greenhouse effect, health hazard

Minimisation by process management

as above

NOx

Ozone formation

In development: conversion from non-catalytic to catalytic

Steam

--

--

Furnaces to destroy sludges and residues

CO2 CO

Greenhouse effect, health hazard

As above, minimisation by process management

as above

NOx

Ozone formation

Currently not state-of-the-art

Dust

Health hazard

Scrubbers, cyclones, dump

Table 2.2.2A Emissions into the Air Pulp and Paper Mills Page 3





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Fumes of bleaching towers, bleach preparation, chlorine transport

Chlorine Chlorine dioxide SO2

Health hazard " "

Extract fumes and wash in scrubbers, return to process

Up to 100

Waste air from transport equipment for raw materials and products

Motor exhaust NOx, CO, HC, CO2

Health hazard, atmospheric effects

Catalysts, diesel operation with soot filters, use of electric vehicles where possible

Up to 90

Paper dryer, paper machine (ditto coating and laminating machines)

Steam

--

--

--

Organic solvents

Health hazard

Gas scrubbing, carbon filters with recovery, also use of water-soluble auxiliaries

Up to 95

Processing of additives, waste air from vacuum pumps

Steam

--

--

--

Waste air from transport equipment for raw materials and products

Motor exhaust, NOx, CO, HC, CO2

Health hazard

Catalysts, diesel with soot filters, use of electric vehicles where possible

Up to 90

Table 2.2.2B Emissions into the Air Typical for the Sector, State-of-the-Art, Limit Values

Table 2.2.2B Emissions into the Air Typical for the Sector, State-of-the-Art, Limit Values




Emission

Source

State-of-the-art mg/Nm3

Typical limit values mg/Nm3

Dust

- Power boiler - Absorption plant, Mg, Ca bisulphite and magnefite process - Lime-burning kiln - Smelt-dissolving tank

less than 50 less than 50 less than 50 less than 50

50 (orm) 50 (orm) 50 (orm)

SO2

- Power boiler - Absorption plant, Mg, Ca bisulphite process - Ditto magnefite process - Lime-burning kiln with TRS burning

less than 50 less than 250 less than 250 less than 400

400 (orm) 700 (orm) 300 (orm) 400 (orm)

CO

- Power boiler - Lime kiln

less than 100 less than 250

cf. TA-Luft generally: oil-fired: 170 solid fuel: 250

Organic C

- Lime kiln

less than 50

150 mg/m3 (TA-Luft)

NOx

- Power boiler - Lime burning kiln

less than 200 less than 900

400 mg/m3 HMW (LRV-K, 1989) (1,500 TA-Luft, rotary kiln for lime)

TRS

- Power boiler - Lime-burning kiln - Smelt-dissolving tank

less than 5 ppm V less than 8 ppm V 8.4 g/t BLS

5 ppm V (EPA) 8 ppm V (EPA) 8.4 g/t BLS (EPA)

Inorganic Chlorine/ Chlorides

- Bleaching plant - Chemical processing

Cl2 and CL: less than 10 mg/m3

Cl2: 5 mg/m3 (TA-Luft Cl: 30 mg/m3 as HCl (TA-Luft)

HMW: Mean hourly value LRV: Luftreinhalteverordnung (ordinance on clean air)




Table 2.2.3 Solid Waste Pulp and Paper Mills

Table 2.2.3 Solid Waste Pulp and Paper Mills Page 1





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Raw material transport and preparation: Wood

Bark Wood shavings

Space required

Burning for energy generation

> 95

Straw

Binding wire

"

Collection, compacting, scrap trade

--

Pulp cleaning

Knots, bundles of fibre, sand

" "

Incineration for energy generation, dumping

> 95 0

Quality Control

Rejected product

"

Return to process

> 85

Chemical recovery, removal of foreign ions

Lime sludge* or lime Sulphate soap**

Ground water pollution Process problems

Recycling in lime- processing industries, dumping Recycling as raw material for chemical works

0 - 80 Up to 100

Waste paper treatment

Iron wire, plastic film, string

Space required

Dumping

--

Waste paper de-inking

Printing ink sludge (may contain heavy metals)

Ground water contamination

Incineration or special dump

Up to 85

* in sulphate and soda pulp mills ** ditto for softwood





Table 2.2.3 Solid Waste Pulp and Paper Mills Page 2





Sources/causes typical in sector

Substances emitted

Impacts

Reduction measures (state- of-the-art) in mill

Degree of reduction (%)

Water and wastewater treatment

Fibre sludge, inorganic sludge, biological sludge

Space required

Recycle or burn fibre sludge

Up to 85

Dump inorganic and biological sludge, under certain conditions also use for soil improvement

--

Wear of consumables

Metal, plastic screens, synthetic textiles (felts), lubricants, cleaning agents

Space required

Return to manufacturer for recycling, dump, burn

--

Mill maintenance

Defective machine parts Packaging material

Return to manufacturer for recycling, (scrap), burn or dump

--

Table 3.1.1 Methods of Wastewater Analysis and Possibilities for Reducing Environmental Impact

Table 3.1.1 Methods of Wastewater Analysis and Possibilities for Reducing Environmental Impact Page 1











Pollutant/ properties

Unit


Analysis method


Methods for elimination or reduction

1

Undissolved substances

mg/l


DEV H2, SM 148, 224


Mechanical treatment, flocculation, biol. treatment

2

Substances which can be precipitated

mg/l


DEV H2, SM 224, z x/1/76


Mechanical clarification, flocculation, biol. treatment

3

Suspended matter

mg/l


Difference from 1 and 2


Flocculation (filtration), biol. treatment

4

Turbidity

cm visibility


DIN standard 38 404-C2, SM 163, 232


Flocculation (filtration), biol. treatment

5

Colours


DIN standard 38 404-C1, SM 118, 206


Flocculation, coagulation, flotation

6

Temperature

°C


DIN standard 38 404-C4, SM 162


Cooling (towers, lagoons, trickling filters)

7

Odour


DEV B1/2, SM 136, 217


8

pH


DEV C5/S5, SM 144, 221


Neutralisation

9

Conductivity

µS/cm


DEV C8, SM 154, 226


Table 3.1.1 Methods of Wastewater Analysis, and Possibilities for Reducing Environmental Impact Page 2











Pollutant/ properties


Unit


Analysis method

Methods for elimination or reduction

10

Total, evaporation, and incineration residue


mg/l


DEV H1/S3, SM 148, 224

11

BOD


mgO2/ l


DEV H5, SM 141, 219 DIN 38409-H91

Biodegradation, aerobic, anaerobic

12

COD


mgO2/ l


SM 142, 220 Z x/2/76 DIN 38409-H41 and -A30 ARAVwV1) no.303

Biodegradation, aerobic, anaerobic

13

Total organic carbon, TOC


mgC/l


SM 138

14

Oxygen


mgO2/ l


DEV G2/J8, SM 140, 218

15

Total nitrogen, organic


mg/l


DEV H11, H12

Biodegradation, aerobic, anaerobic

16

Colloids


mg/l


DEV H3

17

Oils, fats


mg/l


DEV H17, H18 SM 137, 209

Separators

18

Lignin, tannin


mg/l


SM 160

19

Hydrocarbons


µg/l


DEV H15

20

Organic poisons


µg/l


SM 139

Biodegradation

Table 3.1.1 Methods of Waste Water Analysis, and Possibilities for Reducing Environmental Impact Page 3











Pollutant/ properties

Unit


Analysis method


Methods for elimination or reduction

21

Phosphorus

mg/l


ARAVwV no.108


22

Nitrogen

mg/l


ARAVwV no.106/107, 202


23

AOX

g/l


DIN standard 38409-H14, ARAVwV no.302


24

Chloride etc.

mg/l


DEV D5-7, D15, J7, SM 156 - 158, 228


Ion exchange, ultra-filtration, rev. osmosis

25

Nitrate, nitrite

mg/l


DEV D9-10, E5 SM 131-135, 212-216


Biological decomposition

26

Heavy metals

mg/l


SM 211, ARAVwV no.207 (Ca) no.209 (chromium)/214 (Ni)/206 (Pb)/213 (Cu)/215 (Hg)


Flocculation

27

Na+ etc.

mg/l


DEV H13-15, SM 126, 147, 153


Ion exchange, ultra-filtration, rev. osmosis

28

Toxicity and biodegradability


DEV L2-3


29

Population equivalent


DEV L1


30

Toxicity to fish

TF**, %, TEF*


DEV L15, SM231 DIN standard 3842-L20, ARAVwV 401


31

Biological/ ecological water inspection (water quality classes)


DEV M1-7, SM 601-606


DEV: Deutsches Einheitsverfahren [German standardisation procedure]

SM: Standard methods (APHA)

Z: Zellcheming code of practice

1) ARAVwV: Appendix to the Rahmen-Abwasser-Verwaltungsvorschrift of 08.09.1989 [General Administrative Framework Regulation]

* TEF: toxicity emission factor ** TF: toxity to fish

Table 3.1.2A (Minimum) Wastewater Requirements (specific) As at January 1990 in Germany













Type of pulp or paper

COD kg/t max. 2)

BOD kg/t max.

BOD mg /l

AOX kg/t max.

Toxicity to fish TF max.

Substances which can be precipitated ml/l max.


Pulp (generally)

70

5

1**

2


Paper: writing and printing papers, depending on type

5 - 7

0.7 -6

25

0.5

0.5 0.5


Based on waste paper

6

1.2

0.5


Parchment

12

6

0.5

0.5


2) Tonne, air dry = 0.9 t absolutely dry

**) Not applicable to dissolving pulp until 31.12.1992

Table 3.1.2b Pollutant Units for the Measurement of Wastewater Discharges in Germany





No.

Pollutants and pollutant groups assessed

The following units of measurement are equivalent to one pollution unit in each case

Threshold values by concentration and annual quantity


1

Oxidizable substances in chemical oxygen demand (COD)

50 kilograms oxygen

20 milligrams per litre and 250 kilograms annual quantity


2

Phosphorus

3 kilograms

0.1 milligrams per litre and 15 kilograms annual quantity


3

Nitrogen

25 kilograms

5 milligrams per litre and 125 kilograms annual quantity


4

Organic halogen compounds as adsorbable organically bound halogens (AOX)

2 kilograms halogen, calculated as organically bound chlorine

100 micrograms per litre and 10 kilograms annual quantity


5

Metals and their compounds:

and


5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6

Mercury Cadmium Chromium Nickel Lead Copper

20 grams 100 grams 500 grams 500 grams 500 grams 1,000 grams of metal

1 microgram 5 micrograms 50 micrograms 50 micrograms 50 micrograms 100 micrograms per litre

100 grams 500 grams 2.5 kilograms 2.5 kilograms 2.5 kilograms 5 kilograms annual quantity

6

Toxicity to fish

3,000 cubic metres of wastewater divided by TF

TF = 2

TF is the dilution factor at which the wastewater is no longer toxic in the fish test.