2.5 Support in Childbirth
Reports and randomized controlled trials on support in labour by
one single person, a doula, midwife or a nurse, showed that
continuous empathetic and physical support during labour resulted in many
benefits, including shorter labour, significantly less medication and epidural
analgesia, fewer Apgar scores of <7 and fewer operative deliveries (Klaus et
al 1986, Hodnett and Osborn 1989, Hemminki et al 1990, Hofmeyr et al 1991).
This report identifies a doula as a female caregiver, who has
had a basic training in labour and delivery and who is familiar with a wide
variety of care procedures. She provides emotional support consisting of praise,
reassurance, measures to improve the comfort of the mother, physical contact
such as rubbing the mothers back and holding her hands, explanation of
what is going on during labour and delivery and a constant friendly presence.
Such tasks can also be fulfilled by a nurse or midwife, but they often need to
perform technical/medical procedures that can distract their attention from the
mother. However, the constant comforting support of a female caregiver
significantly reduced the anxiety and the feeling of having had a difficult
birth in mothers 24 hours postpartum. It also had a positive effect on the
number of mothers who were still breast-feeding 6 weeks postpartum.
A woman in labour should be accompanied by the people she trusts
and feels comfortable with; her partner, best friend, doula or midwife. In some
developing countries this could also include the TBA. Generally these will be
people she has become acquainted with during the course of her pregnancy.
Professional birth attendants need to be familiar with both the supportive and
the medical tasks they have and be able to perform both with competence and
sensitivity. One of the supportive tasks of the caregiver is to give women as
much information and explanation as they desire and need. Womens privacy
in the birthing setting should be respected. A labouring woman needs her own
room, where the number of attendants should be limited to the essential minimum.
However, in actual practice conditions often differ considerably
from the ideal situation described above. In developed countries women in labour
often feel isolated in labour rooms of large hospitals, surrounded by technical
equipment and without friendly support of caregivers. In developing countries
some large hospitals are so overcrowded with low-risk deliveries that personal
support and privacy are impossible. Home deliveries in developing countries are
often attended by untrained or insufficiently trained caregivers. Under these
circumstances support of the labouring woman is deficient or even absent, for a
significant number of women deliver with no attendant at all.
The implications of the above statements for the location of
birth and the provision of support can be far reaching, because they suggest
that caregivers in childbirth should work on a much smaller scale. Skilled care
in childbirth should be provided at or near to the place where women live,
rather than bringing all women to a large obstetric unit. Large units that
perform 50 to 60 deliveries a day would need to restructure their services to be
able to cater to womens specific needs. Caregivers would need to
reorganise work schedules in order to meet womens need for continuity of
care and support. This also has cost implications and thus becomes a political
issue. Both developing and developed countries need to address and resolve these
issues in their own specific ways.
In conclusion, normal birth, provided it is low-risk, only needs
close observation by a trained and skilled birth attendant in order to detect
early signs of complications. It needs no intervention but encouragement,
support and a little tender loving care. General guidelines can be given as to
what needs to be in place to protect and sustain normal birth. However, each
country willing to invest in these services needs to adapt these guidelines to
its own specific situation and the needs of the women as well as to ensure that
the basics are in place in order to adequately serve women at low, medium and
high risk and those who develop
complications.